#qotd - Wilfred Bion's Art of Listening

One of the most influential of post-Kleinian theorists who come to mind is Bion and his work on furthering the theory of object relations.  Of note, is an influential 4-page paper he wrote on Notes on Memory and Desire - the art of being able to be present in reverie, and being aware of what Memory and Desire does to us internally, and externally (acted out) in the psychotherapy situation.  Have a read if you can get your hands on it - link below.

The purest form of listening is to listen without memory or desire.
— Wilfred Bion
Wilfred Bion - thepsychpractice.jpg

Wilfred Bion (1897-1979) was born in Muttra, northwest India, and was educated at boarding school in England. He was unhappy there, missing his parents, his Aya and the India he loved.

He fought in France in the Tank Regiment during the First World War and was awarded the DSO (Distinguished Service Order), and, by the French Government, the Légion d'Honneur.

After the war Bion took History at Queen's College, Oxford and later went on to study medicine at University College London. After qualifying as a doctor, he spent seven years at the Tavistock Clinic in London, training in psychoanalytic psychotherapy. While there he saw Samuel Beckett for therapeutic interviews. In 1938 he began his first training analysis with John Rickman. This was brought to an end by the outbreak of the Second World War, during which Bion worked with traumatised soldiers in military hospitals.

Around 1946 Bion entered into training analysis with Melanie Klein, and he became a full Member of the British Psychoanalytical Society in 1950.

Bion married twice and had three children; his daughter Parthenope went on to become a gifted analyst in Italy. In 1968, at the age of 71, Bion moved to California. He returned to England shortly before his death in 1979.

Bion’s work and development of Kleinian concepts

While studying at UCL Bion met Wilfred Trotter, another physician interested in the workings of the mind. Trotter’s Instincts of the Herd in Peace and War (1) was an important influence on Bion's interest in group mentality.

Bion’s work with traumatised soldiers during the Second World War, and his role working with Officer Selection Boards, helped form the basis of his ideas expressed later in the papers published as Experiences in Groups.

Bion is best known for the work stemming from his psychoanalysis of patients in psychotic states, by building on and expanding Klein’s concepts of projective identification and the two positions, paranoid-schizoid and depressive, in dynamic equilibrium, and by introducing the notion of Container-Contained (♀ ♂); and by elaborating a theory of thinking with emotional experience at its core. His best-known work, in addition to Experiences in Groups and other papers, are the four books of the sixties - Learning from ExperienceElements of Psycho-AnalysisTransformations, and Attention and Interpretation.

Bion considered that the development of his ideas concerning the inner world of the individual, particularly in relation to thinking and primitive unconscious phantasy, incorporated and transformed his earlier ideas about group mentality. However, he did not receive support from Melanie Klein for the latter ideas, nor for his explanation of countertransference in terms of an expanded version of Klein’s concept of projective identification.

Bion today

An increasing number of analysts are showing an interest in exploring the clinical relevance of Bion’s later ideas, some developed mainly during his time in Los Angeles. The Memoir of the Future is an allusive work which reworks many of Bion’s theoretical ideas in the form of a novel, something he had always wanted to attempt. His concept of ‘O’ still remains something of a challenge to contemporary analysts, but serves to remind us all that the phenomena we study are elusive and somehow ‘behind’ those surface manifestations which strike our sensory and perceptual systems, and that what we normally deal with are transformations of what is really there. Bion’s work continues to be found fresh and clinically relevant to new generations of practising analysts and researchers, in many different fields and in many different parts of the world.

Bion’s work is best viewed not in isolation, in spite of his unique and inimitable style of writing and thinking, but together with that of Herbert Rosenfeld and Hanna Segal.

Key publications

1961 Bion, W. Experiences in Groups. Tavistock.

1962 Bion, W. Learning from Experience. Heinemann.

1963 Bion, W. Elements of Psycho-Analysis. Heinemann.

1965 Bion, W. Transformations. Heinemann.

1970 Bion, W. Attention and Interpretation. Tavistock.

Find the article, "On Memory and Desire" here:

Melanie Klein Today - thepsyhpractice.jpg
buy the book from The Book Depository, free delivery

Melanie Klein Today: Mainly Practice Volume 2 : Developments in Theory and Practice

Edited by  Elizabeth Bott Spillius

Although both Kleinian psychoanalysts and their critics take it for granted that there is a therapeutic technique distinctive to the Kleinian approach, comparatively little has been written about what it is. In Melanie Klein Today, Volume 2, Elizabeth Bott Spillius brings together classic and new papers to make it possible to understand the main elements of the Kleinian therapeutic technique. In recent years there have been important refinements in this technique, notably in regard to the balance to be struck in interpreting destructiveness, the use of the so-called part-object language, and the precise ways to understand and interpret 'acting-in' and the role of the past in the present. This collection draws these developments together and makes clear why an integral part of contemporary Kleinian theory and practice is concerned with the careful scrutiny of the therapeutic process itself. The volume includes detailed accounts of clinical work with both adults and children and takes further the theoretical ideas discussed in Melanie Klein Today, Volume 1. The papers and the editorial commentary in this book together comprise the most illuminating and coherent rationale for the Kleinian technique yet published. The ideas will be of interest to members of many disciplines and a final section includes papers on the application of the Kleinian approach in other fields of work.